Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo
facebook
twitter
youtube
linkedin
instagram
Abierto al públicoBeyond BordersCaribbean Development TrendsCiudades SosteniblesEnergía para el FuturoEnfoque EducaciónFactor TrabajoGente SaludableGestión fiscalGobernarteIdeas MatterIdeas que CuentanIdeaçãoImpactoIndustrias CreativasLa Maleta AbiertaMoviliblogMás Allá de las FronterasNegocios SosteniblesPrimeros PasosPuntos sobre la iSeguridad CiudadanaSostenibilidadVolvamos a la fuente¿Y si hablamos de igualdad?Inicio
Administración pública Agua y saneamiento Ciencia, tecnología e innovación Comercio e integración regional Conocimeinto Abierto Desarrollo infantil temprano Desarrollo urbano y vivienda Educación Energía Género y diversidad Impacto Industrias Creativas Medio ambiente, cambio climático y Salvaguardias Política y gestión fiscal Salud Sin Miedos Trabajo y pensiones
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Enfoque Educación

  • INICIO
  • CATEGORÍAS
    • Desarrollo infantil temprano y educación inicial
    • Educación y trabajo
    • Financiamiento
    • Género y educación
    • Infraestructura y tecnología educativa
    • Sistemas educativos
    • Docentes
  • Autores
  • Español

You can’t make a pig fat by weighing it! – Part I

November 21, 2013 por Carlos Herran - Cynthia Hobbs 6 Comentarios


From measurement to action: Using data to improve learning in the Caribbean

Every year for the past 40 years, thousands of nervous students from the English-speaking Caribbean sit at their school desks’ to take a test that will change their lives. These evaluations are administered by the Caribbean Examination Council (CXC). CXC’s Secondary Education Certificate (CSEC) examinations are applied at the end of compulsory secondary education to approximately 120,000 students from English-speaking Caribbean countries (16 territories currently participate) to measure student performance. CSEC exam results constitute the main credential used to pursue higher education or to enter the job market. These tests are “high stakes” for the individual students because their performance determines their future. Sadly, in many countries less than half of those who sit the exam attain satisfactory pass rates in key areas such as English language and math.

BoyStudying

 

The individual results from these standardized tests, as well as national averages, are given back to Ministries of Education. Some publish them, some discuss them at ministry meetings, and some send the results back to the schools. But rarely are they used systematically to reflect on student and school performance, or to identify learning gaps so teachers can make changes in the teaching/learning process. As a result, the bad news is repeated year after year. In the words of one Caribbean educator, “You can’t make a pig fat by weighing it”.

Critical disconnects lead to inaction or ineffective actions

On October 28-29, 2013, Ministry of Education head planners and statisticians from 14 countries came together for a workshop entitled: “Using data to Improve Education Outcomes in the Caribbean.” The workshop was sponsored by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), in collaboration with the OECS Education Development Management Unit (EDMU) and the CXC. Speakers included regional educators who shared ongoing initiatives in their own countries, and international experts.Miami workshop -5

Miami workshop -1

Photos taken during the workshop by Marcellus Albertin, Head Education Development Management Unit, Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States

Workshop participants discussed why the results of national or international assessments are not used more often to feed back into teacher training, teaching methodology, curriculum, and assessment to improve what happens in the classroom. The participants identified disconnects at the system and school levels.

Tablita1

Most initiatives to improve monitoring and evaluation data focus on assessments to collect the data, improvements in reliability, and development of systems to store and report that data. However, other key questions often not addressed are:

  • Is there a clear vision of what to do with the data?
  • Is there sufficient technical and institutional capacity in the Ministries and at the schools to analyze the data and learn from it to inform policy or improve classroom practices?
  • Do the protagonists (principals and teachers) find the data useful? Why or why not?
  • What can be done to turn the results of student evaluations into useful tools for changing practices at the school and classroom levels?

These questions do not have simple answers. We invite you to share your thoughts. And stay tuned to our next blog post to find out what good practices were identified and what insights were exchanged during the workshop discussions!

 


Archivado bajoEnglish Etiquetado con:#Education, Caribbean, Data, Education Policy, Latin America, pedagogy

Carlos Herran

Carlos Herrán es economista senior/especialista principal de la División de Educación en el Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo. Se incorporó al Banco en 1990 y trabajó como economista a cargo de Estrategias de Paises y Programación de Paises, y estudios económicos y sociales de la División de Economía de Países . Entre 1994 y 1996 el Señor Herrán trabajó como Asesor Principal del Ministerio de Educación de Colombia, donde trabajó en diversos temas, incluyendo el desarrollo y la negociación de los planes de incentivos por docentes , la descentralización y financiación de la educación a los gobiernos subregionales, la planificación del sector y la supervisión y regulación de escuelas privadas. Retornó al BID en 1996 y trabajó como especialista del Sector de Economista y Social en el diseño de programas de educación, el desarrollo social y la reduccion de la pobreza en varios países. Entre 2003-06 estuvo a cargo de las operaciones del sector social en Brasil y publicó dos libros sobre educación y pobreza en Brasil (ver abajo). El Señor Herrán se incorporó a la División de Educación en 2008 , donde ha trabajado en el diseño de diversas operaciones de préstamo y la investigación aplicada. Sus áreas de interés incluyen la Primera Infancia , Educación Secundaria y Post- secundaria y la transición de la escuela al trabajo, la evaluación y la rendición de cuentas y el liderazgo escolar . Antes de trabajar en el BID, trabajó en el Banco Mundial como asesor para el Informe Mundial de Desarrollo sobre Pobreza (1990), como economista del Departamento de Planificación Nacional de Colombia donde trabajó en temas de los mercados laborales y los gastos del sector social. Es el autor de “Reducing Poverty and Inequality in Brazil” (IDB/IPEA, 2005), co-autor de “Secondary Education in Brazil: Time to move forward” (IDB/World Bank, 2000), coautor de “Why do Youngsters drop out of school in Argentina and what can be done against it?” (BID, Documento de Trabajo n º 20 RE1, 2001) y de numerosos artículos sobre educación y cuestiones de política social en América Latina y el Caribe. Ha coordinado los estudios financiados por el BID para el Desarrollo de la Primera Infancia en Chile y sobre Escuelas Secundarias Efectivas en Brasil, que han sido publicados por UNICEF en Chile y INEP de Brasil. El Sr. Herran es un economista de la Universidad de los Andes en Colombia con una Maestría en Economía de Yale University.

Cynthia Hobbs

Cynthia Hobbs is a Lead Education Specialist at the Inter-American Development Bank. She has a deep interest in improving teaching quality, and she has taught in primary schools, universities and in courses for adults. She also has conducted research on teaching practices, including intercultural bilingual math education. Prior to joining the IDB, she worked for 15 years at the World Bank where she also oversaw the preparation and execution of education projects in several areas, including early and pre-primary education, primary and secondary education, youth, and transitions from school to work. Cynthia holds a degree in Psychology from Bates College (USA) and a master's degree in International Education from Harvard University.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Eduardo Velez Bustillo dice

    November 23, 2013 at 3:15 pm

    Cynthia Marie and Carlos
    Good that you are doing this, but let me tell you that CXC is too late in the game…. If you do not start with testing with standards that all stakeholders (especially parents) understand early on, let say 2nd or 3rd grade, it is too late to improve quality of education. So I truly hope you will present in the next posts something on how to measure quality better, more timely, and how parents and other stakeholders are involved in the process to increase accountability. I am looking forward to this discussion.

    Reply
    • Cynthia Hobbs dice

      November 27, 2013 at 9:34 pm

      Eduardo, thanks for your comment. Many of the countries administer national exams in earlier grades as you suggest. For example, in Jamaica they give a Grade 3 test (shifting soon to Grade 2) as well as national literacy and numeracy tests at Grade 4. I would invite others to share their experiences here.

      Reply
  2. Darrell Hull dice

    November 25, 2013 at 11:12 am

    I’ve often wondered why the CSEC scores are not reported on a continuous scale metric, rather than the categorical metric (if I recall, the scores range from 1-6 categories on each of the subject tests, or worse yet to describe the outcome as only pass/fail)? The primary reason for measuring anything, performance included, is to generate variation in the scores so that individuals can be distinguished from one another. There are many items on a single subtest, so I don’t understand why more variation isn’t reported? Reporting scores on a continuous metric would be the only way to identify students for services, possibly through the creation of cut scores to identify individuals with greater needs.

    I have searched before for psychometric evidence on the CSEC (well on all CXC exams actually) and have not been able to find anything. Perhaps some of you could point me to a source? Some transparency on the development of items and scores would be helpful as well.

    Reply
    • Cynthia Hobbs dice

      November 27, 2013 at 9:24 pm

      Darrell, thanks for your comment. I’m hoping CXC will address this. I’ll forward it to the Registrar for a response.

      Reply
  3. Alison dice

    November 25, 2013 at 2:50 pm

    This article raises critical issues for those who have an interest in seeing positive changes in the teaching / learning environments throughout the English speaking Caribbean. I will focus on two issues:

    • What can be done to turn the results of student evaluations into useful tools for changing practices at the school and classroom levels? And
    • How can we actually achieve these changes if teachers have “limited time” and “limited skills” to engage with data and to identify learning gaps of their students.

    The CXC produces fairly comprehensive exam reports after each examination period. I want to draw your attention to the Exam Results Reports (CSEC) January 2013, specifically to the English A report -for ease of reference I’ll include the link for ease of reference ☺
    (https://www.cxc.org/SiteAssets/2013SchoolReports/CSECJanuary2013EnglishA.SR.pdf)
    A few highlights from this report:

    General Comments
    • The Expression profile remains fair…Candidates are encouraged to do more critical reading and discussion.
    • As suggested last year (and probably many times previously – but who is reading and responding to these reports?) ……focus should be on studying “how writers say things and why”

    Detailed Comments (Paper 02 – Free Response)

    • Too many candidates try to get by with lifting chunks of text, “cutting and pasting” them together…
    • We advise that teaching should concentrate on helping students to grasp and reproduce meaning (as opposed to text).
    • …there are persistent problems with Expression and Organization.

    Again, the report repeats recommendations from previous reports. It seems the same error patterns are repeated over and over.

    Perhaps we are overthinking the issue of using data to improve our teaching and learning. Perhaps we need to simply consider how we can facilitate our teachers in creating dynamic, interesting, creative classroom environments. No, I do not mean that we will have “another” teacher professional development workshop!! We have killed those! We need to create spaces where teachers can come together and discuss innovative instructional practices and challenges they are experiencing; spaces where teachers can “have a coffee”, and mentor each other.

    Find a few dynamic teachers in each subject area – particularly English Language and Mathematics – and have them lead out on these “Creative Teacher Meet-Ups”, where they encourage others to share how to get around the challenges of “high stakes testing”; how to overcome the practices of “drill and kill”; or the “cut and paste” mentality; to one of “fun”; to one where “ writing workshops” are encouraged, where our youth are encouraged to, “debate for the sake of debating” …the possibilities are endless.

    Instead of bringing the endless “past papers” into the classes, I believe that our teachers need a different kind of environment where they themselves are encouraged to develop their own skills of inquiry, knowledge and understanding about the young people they work with. It is through this kind of networking and discussion that we will create learning outcomes built on a foundation of understanding and knowledge.

    I worry that my response may seem almost “too simple” or “too easy”. I also know you will say that teachers don’t / won’t have the time to have these “meet-up’s”. On the contrary, I think teachers are yearning for a different kind of discussion. They are as frustrated as we are with the results.

    But in reality, what kind of atmosphere encourages learning? – Even for teachers? Certainly not the same “drill and kill” classrooms that produce the dismal results we see repeatedly? Teachers deserve dynamic spaces to allow for the development of their own creativity and innovation which they can then translate into amazing, – dare I say “fun” and results-oriented, teaching/learning environments.

    …Let’s actually fatten up these pigs, in fact let’s encourage them to squeal with joy….”weeee weeee weeee all the way home”.

    Let’s continue to brainstorm on solutions, there are many more avenues to explore.

    Reply
    • Cynthia Hobbs dice

      November 27, 2013 at 9:38 pm

      Alison, thanks for taking the time to send such a detailed response and for highlighting other sources of information. You’re obviously passionate about teaching and learning. Your suggestions regarding how to motivate teachers are most welcome in this discussion. I hope others will chime in.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

SIGUENOS

Subscribe

Buscar

Enfoque Educación

"Enfoque Educación" es el blog de la División de Educación del BID, un espacio donde nuestros especialistas y autores invitados comparten sus reflexiones, experiencias y conocimientos para promover discusiones informadas sobre temas educativos entre formuladores de política, expertos, maestros, y padres. Nuestra meta: proveer ideas para que las políticas publicas puedan garantizar una enseñanza efectiva y de calidad para todos los niños y jóvenes de América Latina y el Caribe.

Recent Posts

  • Política educativa y resultados: (Casi) Todo está en la implementación. 
  • Estudiantes como ciudadanos globales: 4 formas de desarrollar preparación en IA para aprendices listos para el futuro
  • Explorando la ética de la IA en la educación: una conversación con el chatbot de Peter Singer
  • ‘Los maestros brillantes que me formaron’: homenaje de Bill Gates a sus maestros  
  • IA y educación: cómo hacer posible una verdadera revolución educativa 

Footer

Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo
facebook
twitter
youtube
youtube
youtube

    Blogs escritos por empleados del BID:

    Copyright © Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo ("BID"). Este trabajo está disponible bajo los términos de una licencia Creative Commons IGO 3.0 Reconocimiento-No comercial-Sin Obras Derivadas. (CC-IGO 3.0 BY-NC-ND) y pueden reproducirse con la debida atribución al BID y para cualquier uso no comercial. No se permite ningún trabajo derivado. Cualquier disputa relacionada con el uso de las obras del BID que no se pueda resolver de manera amistosa se someterá a arbitraje de conformidad con el reglamento de la CNUDMI. El uso del nombre del BID para cualquier otro propósito que no sea la atribución, y el uso del logotipo del BID estarán sujetos a un acuerdo de licencia escrito por separado entre el BID y el usuario y no está autorizado como parte de esta licencia CC-IGO. Tenga en cuenta que el enlace proporcionado anteriormente incluye términos y condiciones adicionales de la licencia.


    Blogs escritos por autores externos:

    Para preguntas relacionadas con los derechos de autor para autores que no son empleados del BID, por favor complete el formulario de contacto de este blog.

    Las opiniones expresadas en este blog son las de los autores y no necesariamente reflejan las opiniones del BID, su Directorio Ejecutivo o los países que representan.

    Atribución: además de otorgar la atribución al respectivo autor y propietario de los derechos de autor, según proceda, le agradeceríamos que incluyera un enlace que remita al sitio web de los blogs del BID.



    Política de privacidad

    Derechos de autor © 2025 · Magazine Pro en Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

    Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo

    Aviso Legal

    Las opiniones expresadas en estos blogs son las de los autores y no necesariamente reflejan las opiniones del Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo, sus directivas, la Asamblea de Gobernadores o sus países miembros.

    facebook
    twitter
    youtube
    En este sitio web se utilizan cookies para optimizar la funcionalidad y brindar la mejor experiencia posible. Si continúa visitando otras páginas, se instalarán cookies en su navegador.
    Para obtener más información al respecto, haga clic aquí.
    X
    Manage consent

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT