Inter-American Development Bank
facebook
twitter
youtube
linkedin
instagram
Abierto al públicoBeyond BordersCaribbean Development TrendsCiudades SosteniblesEnergía para el FuturoEnfoque EducaciónFactor TrabajoGente SaludableGestión fiscalGobernarteIdeas MatterIdeas que CuentanIdeaçãoImpactoIndustrias CreativasLa Maleta AbiertaMoviliblogMás Allá de las FronterasNegocios SosteniblesPrimeros PasosPuntos sobre la iSeguridad CiudadanaSostenibilidadVolvamos a la fuente¿Y si hablamos de igualdad?Home
Citizen Security and Justice Creative Industries Development Effectiveness Early Childhood Development Education Energy Envirnment. Climate Change and Safeguards Fiscal policy and management Gender and Diversity Health Labor and pensions Open Knowledge Public management Science, Technology and Innovation  Trade and Regional Integration Urban Development and Housing Water and Sanitation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Ideas Matter

  • HOME
  • CATEGORIES
    • Behavioral Economics
    • Environment and Climate Change
    • Macroeconomics and Finance
    • Microeconomics and Competitiveness
    • Politics and Institutions
    • Social Issues
  • Authors
  • Spanish

Fiscal Rules for a Debt-Plagued Region

March 3, 2023 by Martín Ardanaz - Eduardo Cavallo - Alejandro Izquierdo Leave a Comment


With a long history of recurrent and costly debt crises, Latin American governments have long sought to find a way to curb the fiscal deficits that stoke the debt problem. Those efforts gathered steam over the course of the 2000s when numerous governments in the region began adopting fiscal rules, which seek to curb politicians’ ability to increase spending under political and electoral pressure and base fiscal policies instead on numerical indicators related to budget balances or macroeconomic performance.

But, as our research shows, the mere adoption of fiscal rules is insufficient to ensure fiscal health and sustainable debt-to-GDP ratios.  By 2021, for example, 106 countries in the world had adopted fiscal rules, including around 15 in Latin America and the Caribbean. Examining our global sample for the period 2000-2019, however, we found that there was not much difference in average debt growth for countries during  periods when they had a least one fiscal rule in place and periods when they had no fiscal rule at all. Problems designing rules-based fiscal frameworks and low compliance, among others, hindered effectiveness. Indeed, Latin American countries were compliant with the spending restrictions of their fiscal rules less than one third of the time.

Designing Fiscal Rules

The challenges of designing fiscal rules are complex. Early fiscal rules were criticized as being too oriented around the achievement of headline budget balances, which limited policymakers ability to spend in the face of economic shocks. Such rules also encouraged policymakers to engage in procyclical behavior; i.e., spending too much when the economy was doing well without concern for saving for potentially bad times in the future.  But when Chile (2001) and Colombia (2011) implemented more sophisticated structural balance rules that instead tried to take into account output and commodity prices, those efforts also fell short in reducing debt growth despite strenuous efforts at compliance. In Colombia, for example, where the rules were oriented around potential GDP growth and the long-term price of oil, the nation’s principal export, predictions turned out to be far too optimistic, leading to fiscal policy that was more expansionary than it should have been and increasing debt levels.

None of this is to say that well-designed fiscal rules cannot make an important difference. Our study shows that average debt-to-GDP growth falls more than three percentage points per year with high quality fiscal rules, compared to low quality ones, and that debt volatility falls under strong quality rules to one third of the volatility under low quality ones.  

Aiming for a Prudent Level of Debt and Better Expenditure Allocation

A key innovation in designing higher quality rules is to set a maximum level of acceptable debt and then calibrate a more “prudent” level, which can serve as a medium-term fiscal policy “anchor” or target. As Chile and Colombia have recently done, countries can then implement a feedback mechanism based on the outstanding amount of public debt, applying more adjustment pressure as outstanding debt levels exceed prudent ones.  That allows them to ensure that debt does not grow to levels that undermine fiscal sustainability with an embedded self-regulating mechanism.                   

Proper fiscal rule design can also lead to better expenditure allocation, particularly when it comes to protecting expenditures that typically don’t have strong political support despite their proven economic benefits, like public investment. Flexible features in fiscal rules can  safeguard vital public spending on capital investments, including growth stimulating infrastructure, and provide escape clauses to allow governments to temporarily suspend the rules in the midst of crises, like the COVID-19 pandemic. It has been shown that flexible rules that explicitly or implicitly protect public investment are more growth-friendly. However, once flexible arrangements like escape clauses are included, rules should provide guidance for a return to compliance in the aftermath of a negative shock so as not to lose credibility.

Complementary Fiscal Institutions  

Political will and enforcement are essential for increasing fiscal rule effectiveness. Independent, non-partisan fiscal councils can play a critical role in this regard, verifying whether rules are being complied with, recommending ways to return to compliance when they are not, and inflicting reputational costs on governments that ignore them. They may even have a mandate to enforce a return rule to compliance after repeated periods of non-compliance.

All these issues have come to the fore since the pandemic as governments realized how necessary it was to fix the shortcomings of existing fiscal frameworks.

Evidence makes it abundantly clear that fiscal rules alone are not enough to stabilize debt-to-GDP ratios and ensure fiscal sustainability. But in a region where fiscal indiscipline and excessive debt have often been a curse; where the average public debt-to-GDP ratio is currently well above the average of preceding decades; and where globally rising interest rates will boost the cost of debt financing, they can make an immense contribution when well designed and enforced.  Fiscal policies need to have a clear long-term objective. They need to have an explicit anchor that corresponds to debt levels, and complementary institutions, like fiscal councils, that bolster compliance with numerical rules. Reforms that move in that direction will help keep debt in check, adding to efforts to stoke greater growth, equity and sustainability in challenging times.  


Filed Under: Macroeconomics and Finance Tagged With: #debt

Martín Ardanaz

Martin Ardanaz es especialista senior de la División Fiscal (FMM) a cargo del diseño y supervisión de proyectos de fortalecimiento de la gestión y política fiscal en Perú. En complemento al trabajo operativo, lidera una una agenda de investigación aplicada en diversas áreas de finanzas públicas, incluyendo el funcionamiento de las reglas fiscales, los impactos macroeconómicos de la política fiscal, y la economía política de las reformas fiscales. Su investigación ha sido publicada en revistas especializadas como IMF Economic Review, World Development y Journal of International Money and Finance, entre otras.

Eduardo Cavallo

Eduardo Cavallo is Principal Economist at the Research Department of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) in Washington DC. Prior to joining the IDB, Eduardo was a Vice-President and Senior Latin American Economist for Goldman Sachs in New York. Eduardo had already worked at the IDB as a Research Economist between 2006 and 2010. Before that he served as a research fellow at the Center for International Development (CID), a visiting scholar at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, and a member of the faculty at the Kennedy School of Government's Summer Program. In Argentina he co-founded Fundación Grupo Innova. Eduardo’s research interests are in the fields of international finance and macroeconomics with a focus on Latin America. He has published in several academic journals, and is the co-editor of the books “Building Opportunities for Growth in a Challenging World” (IDB, 2019); “A Mandate to Grow” (IDB, 2018); “Saving for Development: how Latin America and the Caribbean can save more and better” (Palgrave, 2016) and “Dealing with an International Credit Crunch: Policy Responses to Sudden Stops in Latin America” (IDB, 2009). He holds a Ph.D. in Public Policy and an MPP from Harvard University, and a B.A. in Economics from Universidad de San Andres (UdeSA) in Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Alejandro Izquierdo

Alejandro Izquierdo is Deputy Director and Head of the Macro Group at the Research Department of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB). He previously held positions as interim Chief Economist and Manager of the Research Department, Regional Economic Advisor for Mexico and Central America, and Principal Economist across the IDB. Alejandro spearheaded the IDB’s Annual Macroeconomic Report for several years and is currently co-director of the Columbia University-IDB executive program on international financial issues in emerging markets. He has also led IDB’s flagship product, the Development in the Americas, on issues such as credit and public expenditure in Latin America. Before his career at the IDB, Alejandro worked at the World Bank in the Department of Economic Policy, and taught courses on macroeconomics and international finance at several Latin American universities. He has several publications in professional journals and edited volumes. He holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the University of Maryland, an M.S. from Instituto Torcuato Di Tella, Argentina, and a B.A. in Economics from Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us

Subscribe

Search

Related posts

  • The Imperatives of Fiscal Health
  • Fiscal Rules for Commodity-Dependent Economies
  • The Good, Bad and Unexpected of Fiscal Rules
  • Fiscal Fatigue in Latin America and the Caribbean: A Growing Threat
  • Debt, Growth, and Interest Rates: Assessing Sustainability in Latin America and the Caribbean

About this blog

The blog of the IDB's Research Department shares ideas that matter on public policy and development in Latin America and the Caribbean.

Footer

Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo
facebook
twitter
youtube
youtube
youtube

    Blog posts written by Bank employees:

    Copyright © Inter-American Development Bank ("IDB"). This work is licensed under a Creative Commons IGO 3.0 Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives. (CC-IGO 3.0 BY-NC-ND) license and may be reproduced with attribution to the IDB and for any non-commercial purpose. No derivative work is allowed. Any dispute related to the use of the works of the IDB that cannot be settled amicably shall be submitted to arbitration pursuant to the UNCITRAL rules. The use of the IDB's name for any purpose other than for attribution, and the use of IDB's logo shall be subject to a separate written license agreement between the IDB and the user and is not authorized as part of this CC- IGO license. Note that link provided above includes additional terms and conditions of the license.


    For blogs written by external parties:

    For questions concerning copyright for authors that are not IADB employees please complete the contact form for this blog.

    The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the IDB, its Board of Directors, or the countries they represent.

    Attribution: in addition to giving attribution to the respective author and copyright owner, as appropriate, we would appreciate if you could include a link that remits back the IDB Blogs website.



    Privacy Policy

    Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

    Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo

    Aviso Legal

    Las opiniones expresadas en estos blogs son las de los autores y no necesariamente reflejan las opiniones del Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo, sus directivas, la Asamblea de Gobernadores o sus países miembros.

    facebook
    twitter
    youtube
    This site uses cookies to optimize functionality and give you the best possible experience. If you continue to navigate this website beyond this page, cookies will be placed on your browser.
    To learn more about cookies, click here
    X
    Manage consent

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
    Non-necessary
    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
    SAVE & ACCEPT